Raingardens are technically designed gardens that filter and manage the flow of local rainwater, to avoid flooding and enable growth of plants and healthy habitats for animals. The winning pilot in this year’s Innovation Challenge investigates how we can use hard waste in raingardens at Fishermans Bend, a low-lying area particularly prone to flooding.
Remix Raingardens seeks to enable climate resilience through implementing a sustainable and cost-effective drainage design. Using layers of locally generated waste materials, such as concrete, organic matter, wood, glass and more, the gardens will close the loop on local waste while contributing to the unique character of Fishermans Bend. Drought-resistant plants will help us understand if the gardens can filter water as well as sustain healthy plant life.
Sensors will be used to capture data for a variety of different designs with different waste products to understand the viability of the idea and to understand the impact of the raingardens on water management, micro-climate, soil and plant health, and the local community.
Through demonstrating positive impacts and educating the community through transparency, these raingardens will inspire more circular economy innovation.
This concept was pitched by Amira Moshinsky, the winning proposal of the Fishermans Bend Innovation Challenge. It is being implemented in partnership with the Victorian Government, Fishermans Bend, Development Victoria and University of Melbourne Opportunity Lab.From 26 April 2023, Remix Raingardens pilot was installed on the footpath at 80a Turner Street, Port Melbourne for a minimum of six months. To follow the process and see behind-the-scenes footage, follow the pilot on Instagram. Or, click the Follow button above to get updates for each stage of the pilot.
Address: Footpath at 80a Turner Street, Port Melbourne
Contact us: email@example.com
Raingarden performance dashboard
This dashboard shows results from lab tests that analyse the quality of the stormwater after passing through the gardens.
On the dashboard, ‘poor’ means when there are more contaminants, ‘moderate’ means 0 to 45% reduction of contaminants, and a greater than 45% reduction of contaminants is 'good'. There have been two rounds of lab tests already and another round of tests will be shared soon. We predict the next tests will show an improvement in their performance.
The dashboard will also be updated to include data from some of our sensors including water level sensors and soil moisture sensors. We will also be adding data about the average plant health per raingarden. Currently, all plants are healthy, however we are closely monitoring them.
What we are trying to understand
The objective of this pilot is to help us understand:
- If recycled material raingardens can perform as successfully as conventional raingardens.
- How well plants grow in raingardens made from recycled waste materials.
- The most effective design strategies for layering local waste in raingardens.
- How useful locally produced hard waste is for filtering water.
- Which waste materials can be repurposed into raingardens.
- How much waste can be diverted from landfill to local raingardens.
- If we can educate the public about water management and circular economies through well-designed raingardens incorporating sensors.
The pilot process
Before we commence testing of the waste materials, the pilot team undertook the following activities:
- desktop research
- literature reviews
- professional consultations
- planning project stages, deliverables and investment of funding.
This process was completed in September 2022. Some research and planning will continue throughout the pilot as required.
What we learned
As a result of this process, we discovered projects experimenting with a bioretention system that is partially made from recycled materials (a bioretention system is one that filters pollutants and nutrients, like a raingarden). We didn't find any projects using only recycled materials as a filtration system from only local sources. In this stage we also identified key success criteria to apply to Remix Raingardens to see how these raingardens perform against a typical raingarden.
After planning and research, the pilot team conducted a series of tests in a nursery environment comparing the effectiveness of different waste materials used for water filtration, infiltration and plant growth.
A total of 20 small-scale tests will use recovered waste materials like crushed glass, street sweepings, aggregated concrete, crushed brick, timber, food and other organic waste in layered configurations. Water will be poured over these small tests and the flow, amount and quality of the water that comes through the garden will be measured.
Baseline tests using conventional raingarden materials like gravel, sand and soil will enable the project team to make comparisons and understand the viability of different waste material compositions.
Key findings will be shared here and will inform the following stages.
What we did
In a Parkville nursery, we’ve been conducting tests on raingardens made from different materials, conventional materials and four types of recycled materials.
Raingardens have a series of layers to effectively manage and filter water. Based on research, we focused our initial testing on the filter layer, the layer that stops contaminants, rubbish and sediment from entering the water systems.
In the control gardens we used standard materials (conventional, white-washed sand and soil) for the filter layer (commonly called the ‘filter media’). In the other gardens, we used a variety of recycled materials to mimic typical sand and soil ingredients. A total of 20 gardens with different mixtures were created to ensure quality testing.
Recycled materials can be categorised into sand and soil materials based on their characteristics.
Recycled ‘sand’ materials:
- crushed brick, aggregate and recycled sand - we will call this ‘Construction sand’ in testing
- 100 per cent crushed glass – we will call this ‘Glass sand’ in testing.
Recycled 'soil’ materials:
- food waste and street sweepings with a higher concentration of food waste – we will call this 'High food soil’ in testing
- food waste and street sweeping budget ‘soils’ - we will call this 'Low food soil’ in testing.
The recycled ‘soil’ and ‘sand’ materials were combined to create four different compositions based on research and advice from industry experts.
Simulated stormwater made to mimic typical Melbourne stormwater were used on the gardens, with the filtered results sent to a lab for analysis to determine the effectiveness of the filter materials.
What we tested for
To understand the effectiveness of our recycled raingardens, we compared the test gardens with our control gardens.
We also measured the filtered water to detect the different levels of contaminants and amount of sediment remaining. We test specifically for any remaining nitrogen, phosphorous and water sediment (Total Suspended Solids – TSS) in the filtered water. Nitrogen is used by plants for lots of leaf growth and color while Phosphorous helps plants form new roots, make seeds, fruit and flowers and fight disease. Cloudy water due to sediment means there are particles in the water suggesting impurities or contaminants.
An effective raingarden reduces amounts of contaminants and sediment from stormwater.
What we learned
The results from our first round of labs tests are varied yet promising. While some raingardens incorporating waste materials perform like the control raingardens, others are not removing enough contaminants and sediments.
The graph below represents lab tests of the five different types of raingardens. By comparing the control garden results against the others, an assessment can be made on which filter materials are performing similarly. We found while the gardens that use crushed glass or 'Glass sand' seem to be removing some TSS or total suspended solids, rather than removing phosphorous and nitrogen, they’re actually adding them into the water.
Alternatively, the gardens with the ‘Construction sand' and soil made from food waste and street sweepings (High Food and Low Food) are performing similarly to the control garden – even a little better!
We have also been trialing a native plant called Carex Appressa in the gardens. This is a species commonly used in raingardens for its ability to filter nitrogen. It is growing well in all the raingardens. We will plant Carex and a variety of other plants in the gardens in Fishermans Bend to continue testing plants.
We will continue to water the nursery gardens and do another round of lab tests. This stage is not yet complete and we’ll update this page with findings soon.
Once thorough testing has determined which waste materials are most useful in a raingarden design, a pilot design will be developed and trialed in Fishermans Bend over an extended period.
During this stage, the site for the pilot will be determined in collaboration with planners and experts, to enable both valuable testing and community collaboration.
A prototype will be made in the Parkville nursery during this stage, to ensure the design is resilient to withstand testing at Fishermans Bend.
This stage will also include planning how we will use technology to capture data about the pilot. This might include pedestrian sensors to measure community engagement, micro-climate sensors to measure temperature and humidity around the gardens, soil moisture and acidity, water flow rates and more.
Finally, development of the design will include signage and communication tools to share with the community and invite feedback.
What we’ve done
Together with students from the University of Melbourne Makerspace we have developed the design of the raingarden. The design will be tested on Turner Street in Fishermans Bend.
Key considerations made include the number of different raingardens to be tested, which sensors to be used to capture data, how stormwater is used for testing, how to best share information with the community and how we capture water for lab testing.
Below is a render of the concept design.
We continue to develop the design and plan to install the raingardens on Turner Street, Fishermans Bend by March.
The Fishermans Bend installation will consist of a series of raingardens. Over a period of several months, sensors will capture a variety of data so we can understand the viability of using waste materials in raingardens.
Signage will describe the pilot and enable community input.
The length of this stage will depend on the performance of the raingardens. We will measure the gardens through collecting sensor data and undertaking observational analysis to understand the viability of raingardens that incorporate recycled materials.
During this stage, there will be opportunities for the community to learn about the pilot and share thoughts and feedback. A dashboard will be published and made accessible to the community to share data and insights.
The final pilot stage will involve analysing all collected data to understand the viability of this concept.
This stage may also include developing a design guide for how to use recycled materials in raingardens that successfully filter and manage rainwater while enabling resilient plant life.
Remix Raingardens was open for visiting from 26 April 2023. We are using sensors, lab tests and observational analysis to measure Remix Raingardens.
We will share a live data dashboard soon, more information on the technology, the plants and the waste we're putting to the test. Hit ‘follow’ to stay updated.
How to get involved
Follow this pilot at the button above to get updates for each stage of the pilot and hear about community engagement opportunities.
To follow the testing process and see behind-the-scenes footage, follow the pilot on Instagram.
We're using up to 40 sensors to help collect data about the raingardens.
We will share a dashboard here soon to show how they are performing.
Our sensors include:
- 16 soil moisture sensors – Edaphic tensionmeters and Enviropro probes from Wildeye, connected to data loggers and solar panels
- 10 water level sensors in the gardens and stormwater tank - created by Monash BoSL Lab
- 10 sensors capturing information on turbidity or sediment in the stormwater - created by Monash BoSL Lab
- 3 sensors recording visits based on nearby chair usage – Yabby movement sensors
- 1 sensor capturing micro-climate data - Netvox temperature and humidity sensor.
Sensors use a variety of battery and solar power to run, sending data via LoRaWan and phone networks to City of Melbourne and Monash BoSL Lab to analyse. No personal information is being collected. We will keep this data permanently for any future analysis.